Evaluation on nature reserve management effectiveness of mitigation and adaptation on climate change: A case study of 12 typical nature reserves in Guangxi

doi:10.17520/biods.2019352

Abstract

Abstract:

Nature reserve establishment is vital to biodiversity conservation and play a key role in mitigating and adapting to climate change. The pressure for increased biodiversity conservation is also increasing due to climate change, but effective management must consider climate change impacts when managing nature reserves. Nature reserves require adaptive management techniques to cope with climate change threats, but to date, there are no management evaluation tools for the mitigation and adaptation of climate change globally. In the past half century, Guangxi’s temperature has risen continuously and extreme weather events have increased in frequency, seriously impacting Guangxi biological habitats. This paper suggests the management effectiveness assessment tool of mitigation and adaptation on climate change (MEATMACC), based on the management effectiveness tracking tool (METT), to use as a management framework to mitigate and adapt to climate change in nature reserves. This paper also evaluated and analyzed 12 nature reserves in Guangxi by using both evaluation tools. National nature reserves scored 28.98% and 43.91% higher (METT and MEATMACC) than non-national nature reserves, respectively. MEATMACC scores were significantly different between national and non-national nature reserves but no significant differences in METT scores. Additionally, the scoring rate of METT and MEATMACC is linearly correlated without significant differences. There is highly significant difference in three elements’ scoring rate that context, planning and outcomes between METT and MEATMACC. The results show that policy and technical support for climate change mitigation and adaptation in nature reserve still needs to be strengthened.

Key words: nature reserve, Guangxi, climate change, management effectiveness evaluation

Bin Feng, Diqiang Li, Yuguang Zhang, Yadong Xue. Evaluation on nature reserve management effectiveness of mitigation and adaptation on climate change: A case study of 12 typical nature reserves in Guangxi[J]. Biodiv Sci, 2020, 28(8): 1026-1035.

Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

URL: https://www.biodiversity-science.net/EN/10.17520/biods.2019352

https://www.biodiversity-science.net/EN/Y2020/V28/I8/1026

Figures/Tables 5

References 29

[1]	Abrahms B, Dipietro D, Graffis A, Hollander A (2017) Managing biodiversity under climate change: Challenges, frameworks, and tools for adaptation. Biodiversity and Conservation, 17, 1-17.
[2]	Belle EM, Stolton S, Dudley N (2012) Protected Area Management Effectiveness: A Regional Framework and Additional METT Module for Monitoring the Effects of Climate Change. UNEP-WCMC, Cambridge.
[3]	CBD Secretariat (2010) Decision Adopted by the Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity at Its Tenth Meeting. CBD, Nagoya.
[4]	Dudley N, Stolton S, Belokurov A, Krueger L, Lopoukhine N, MacKinnon K, Sandwith T, Sekhran N (2010) Natural Solutions: Protected Areas Helping People Cope with Climate Change. IUCN-WCPA, TNC, UNDP, WCS, The World Bank, WWF, Gland, Washington, DC, New York.
[5]	Fan JS, Li JS, Xia R, Hu LL, Li G (2014) Assessing the impact of climate change on the habitat distribution of the giant panda in the Qinling Mountains of China. Ecological Modeling, 274, 12-20.
[6]	Forest II, Dylan C, John C (2015) Biodiversity increases the resistance of ecosystem productivity to climate extremes. Nature, 526, 574-577. DOI URL PMID
[7]	Gross JE, Woodley S, Welling LA, Watson JE (2016) Adapting to climate change: Guidance for protected area managers and planners. In: Best Practice Protected Area Guidelines Series. IUCN, Gland.
[8]	Hannah L, Midgley G, Andelman S, Araújo M, Hughes G, Martinez-Meyer E, Pearson R, Williams P (2007) Protected area needs in a changing climate. Frontiers in Ecology and Environment, 5, 131-138.
[9]	He JL, Xie M, Huang Z, Li YL, Huang XS, Zhou ML (2016) Climate change in Guangxi. Journal of Meteorological Research and Application, 37(3), 11-15. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[ 何洁琳, 谢敏, 黄卓, 李艳兰, 黄雪松, 周美丽 (2016) 广西气候变化事实. 气象研究与应用, 373, 11-15.]
[10]	Heller NE, Zavaleta ES (2009) Biodiversity management in the face of climate change: A review of 22 years of recommendations. Biological Conservation, 142, 1-32.
[11]	Hockings M, Stolton S, Dudley N (2010) Data credibility: What are the ‘right’ data for evaluating management effectiveness of protected areas? New Directions for Evaluation, 122, 53-63.
[12]	Hockings M, Stolton S, Leverington F, Dudley N, Courrau J (2006) Evaluating Effectiveness: A Framework for Assessing Management Effectiveness of Protected Areas, 2nd edn. IUCN, Gland.
[13]	IPCC(2007) Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
[14]	IPCC(2014) Climate Change 2014: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability (Summary for policymakers). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
[15]	IUCN, UNEP-WCMC (2019) Protected Planet: The Global Database on Protected Areas Management Effectiveness (GD-PAME). UNEP-WCMC, IUCN, Cambridge.
[16]	Kathy MK, Nigel D, Trevor S (2011) Natural solutions: Protected areas helping people to cope with climate change. Oryx, 45, 461-462. DOI URL
[17]	Lemieux CJ, Thompson JL, Dawson J, Schuster RM (2012) Natural resource manager perceptions of agency performance on climate change. Journal of Environmental Management, 114, 178-189. DOI URL PMID
[18]	Li HD, Shen WS, Liu HY, Zhang T (2015) State, problems and countermeasures of climate change risk management at nature reserve in China. World Forestry Research, 28(5), 69-73. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[ 李海东, 沈渭寿, 刘海月, 张涛 (2015) 我国自然保护区应对气候变化风险现状、问题与对策. 世界林业研究, 285, 69-73.]
[19]	Masumbuko B, Somda J (2014) Analysis of the Links Between Climate Change, Protected Areas and Communities in West Africa. UNEP-WCMC, Cambridge.
[20]	Rannow S, Macgregor NA, Albrecht J, Crick HQ, Forster M, Heiland S, Janauer G, Morecroft MD, Neubert M, Sarbu A (2014) Managing protected areas under climate change: Challenges and priorities. Environmental Management, 54, 732-743. DOI URL PMID
[21]	Scheffers BR, De ML, Bridge TC, Hoffmann AA, Pandolfi JM, Corlett RT, Butchart SM, Pearce-Kelly P, Kovacs KM, Dudgeon D (2016) The broad footprint of climate change from genes to biomes to people. Science, 354, aaf7671-aaf7679.
[22]	Tanner-Mcallister LS, Rhodes J, Hockings M (2014) Community and park manager’s perceptions of protected area management: A Southeast Queensland study. Australasian Journal of Environmental Management, 21, 320-336.
[23]	Tanner-Mcallister LS, Rhodes J, Hockings M (2017) Managing for climate change on protected areas: An adaptive management decision making framework. Journal of Environmental Management, 204, 510-518. DOI URL PMID
[24]	Tanner-Mcallister LS, Rhodes J, Hockings M (2018) A comparison of climate change impacts on park values on four Queensland World Heritage National Parks in Australia. Australasian Journal of Environmental Management, 25, 1-18.
[25]	TNC (2009) Conservation Action Planning Guidelines for Developing Strategies in the Face of Climate Change. The Nature Conservacy, Salt Lake City.
[26]	UNEP-WCMC, IUCN (2016) Protected Planet Report 2016: How Protected Areas Contribute to Achieving Global Targets for Biodiversity. UNEP-WCMC, Cambridge & IUCN, Gland.
[27]	UNEP-WCMC, IUCN, NGS (2018) Protected Planet Report 2018. UNEP-WCMC, Cambridge; IUCN, Gland & NGS, Washington, DC.
[28]	Wu JG, Wang L, Yang YW, Dai SF, Liu JQ, Zhu G (2011) Nature reserves need to face the challenge of climate change. Environment Protection, 12(4), 30-32. (in Chinese)
	[ 吴建国, 王亮, 杨永伟, 代拴发, 刘建泉, 朱高 (2011) 自然保护区还需面对气候变化挑战. 环境保护, 124, 30-32.]
[29]	Xue DY, Wu JY, Zhao FH (2012) Actions, progress and prospects in implementation of the Convention on Biological Diversity during the past 20 years in China. Biodiversity Science, 20, 623-632. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[ 薛达元, 武建勇, 赵富伟 (2012) 中国履行《生物多样性公约》二十年: 行动、进展与展望. 生物多样性, 20, 623-632.]

编号 No.	评价内容 Evaluation content	分数 Score
一	背景 Context	23
1	法律地位 Legal status	3
2	规章条例 Nature reserve regulations	3
附加项Additional point	自然保护区出台了极端气候事件的应急方案 Nature reserves developed emergency plans for extreme weather events	1
3	脆弱性 Vulnerability	3
附加项 Additional point	开展了脆弱性评估 A vulnerability assessment was carried out in the nature reserve	1
4	不利影响 Negative influence	3
5	管理执行 Law enforcement	3
6	资源清单 Resource inventory	3
7	合作伙伴 Partner	3
二	规划 Planning	14
8	管理目标 Management objectives	3
9	规划设计 Planning and design	3
附加项 Additional point	自然保护区存在天然或人为的基因交流隔断 There is natural or artificial gene communication barriers in nature reserve	1
附加项 Additional point	规划设计已充分考虑应对气候变化影响的因素 Impact of climate change has considered when the nature reserve was planning	1
10	管理计划 Management plan	3
附加项 Additional point	应对气候变化工作已纳入管理计划 Climate change response has been incorporated into the management plan	1
	建立了制度和程序, 定期审查和更新管理计划 Established systems and procedures to review and update management plans on a regular basis	1
	监测评价和研究结果能充分反映在管理计划中 The results of monitoring, research and evaluation can be fully reflected in the management plan	1
三	投入 Inputs	16
11	科学研究 Scientific research	3
12	员工数量 Number of employees	3
13	资金预算 Funding budget	3
14	固定预算 Fixed budget	3
15	设施设备 Equipment and facilities	3
附加项 Additional point	具有应对极端气候事件的设备设施 The nature reserve has facilities to deal with extreme weather events	1
四	过程 Process	32
16	监测评估 Monitoring and evaluation	3
附加项 Additional point	选择了针对气候变化的监测指标并实施了监测 The monitoring indicators was confirmed and monitoring is conducted	1
附加项 Additional point	气候变化监测评估的结果应用于管理决策依据 The results of climate change monitoring is contributed to decision making	1
17	资源管理 Resource management	3
18	人事管理 Human management	3

编号 No.	评价内容 Evaluation content	分数 Score
一	背景 Context	23
1	法律地位 Legal status	3
2	规章条例 Nature reserve regulations	3
附加项Additional point	自然保护区出台了极端气候事件的应急方案 Nature reserves developed emergency plans for extreme weather events	1
3	脆弱性 Vulnerability	3
附加项 Additional point	开展了脆弱性评估 A vulnerability assessment was carried out in the nature reserve	1
4	不利影响 Negative influence	3
5	管理执行 Law enforcement	3
6	资源清单 Resource inventory	3
7	合作伙伴 Partner	3
二	规划 Planning	14
8	管理目标 Management objectives	3
9	规划设计 Planning and design	3
附加项 Additional point	自然保护区存在天然或人为的基因交流隔断 There is natural or artificial gene communication barriers in nature reserve	1
附加项 Additional point	规划设计已充分考虑应对气候变化影响的因素 Impact of climate change has considered when the nature reserve was planning	1
10	管理计划 Management plan	3
附加项 Additional point	应对气候变化工作已纳入管理计划 Climate change response has been incorporated into the management plan	1
	建立了制度和程序, 定期审查和更新管理计划 Established systems and procedures to review and update management plans on a regular basis	1
	监测评价和研究结果能充分反映在管理计划中 The results of monitoring, research and evaluation can be fully reflected in the management plan	1
三	投入 Inputs	16
11	科学研究 Scientific research	3
12	员工数量 Number of employees	3
13	资金预算 Funding budget	3
14	固定预算 Fixed budget	3
15	设施设备 Equipment and facilities	3
附加项 Additional point	具有应对极端气候事件的设备设施 The nature reserve has facilities to deal with extreme weather events	1
四	过程 Process	32
16	监测评估 Monitoring and evaluation	3
附加项 Additional point	选择了针对气候变化的监测指标并实施了监测 The monitoring indicators was confirmed and monitoring is conducted	1
附加项 Additional point	气候变化监测评估的结果应用于管理决策依据 The results of climate change monitoring is contributed to decision making	1
17	资源管理 Resource management	3
18	人事管理 Human management	3

编号 No.	评价内容 Evalution content	分数 Score
附加项 Additional point	管理人员有应对气候变化资源管理的能力或技术 Managers have the capacity or skills to manage resources to deal with climate change	1
19	能力建设 Capacity building	3
附加项 Additional point	管理人员接受应对气候变化的管理培训 Managers are trained in climate change management	1
20	预算管理 Budget management	3
21	设备设施维护 Equipment and facility maintenance	3
22	宣传教育 Publicity and education	3
附加项 Additional point	宣传教育涉及气候变化对保护区影响内容 The publicity and education involves the impacts of climate change and mitigation and adaptation of nature reserves	1
23	利益相关者 Stakeholders	3
24	公众参与 Public participation	3
五	产出 Outputs	7
25	公众设施 Public facilities	3
26	管理成效 Management efficiency	3
附加项 Additional point	积极规划恢复退化地区的保护区和/或保护区缓冲区 Active planning for conservation and/or conservation buffer zones in degraded areas	1
六	影响 Outcomes	8
27	经济效益 Economic benefit	3
附加项 Additional point	安排有改善社区居民经济和生活条件的项目 In the process of resource management, conservation areas arrange projects to improve the economic and living conditions of community residents	1
附加项 Additional point	争取了国内外减缓和适应气候变化的资金 Nature reserve has secured domestic and international funding for climate change mitigation and adaptation, such as REDD and CCBA	1
28	可持续发展 Sustainable development	3

编号 No.	评价内容 Evalution content	分数 Score
附加项 Additional point	管理人员有应对气候变化资源管理的能力或技术 Managers have the capacity or skills to manage resources to deal with climate change	1
19	能力建设 Capacity building	3
附加项 Additional point	管理人员接受应对气候变化的管理培训 Managers are trained in climate change management	1
20	预算管理 Budget management	3
21	设备设施维护 Equipment and facility maintenance	3
22	宣传教育 Publicity and education	3
附加项 Additional point	宣传教育涉及气候变化对保护区影响内容 The publicity and education involves the impacts of climate change and mitigation and adaptation of nature reserves	1
23	利益相关者 Stakeholders	3
24	公众参与 Public participation	3
五	产出 Outputs	7
25	公众设施 Public facilities	3
26	管理成效 Management efficiency	3
附加项 Additional point	积极规划恢复退化地区的保护区和/或保护区缓冲区 Active planning for conservation and/or conservation buffer zones in degraded areas	1
六	影响 Outcomes	8
27	经济效益 Economic benefit	3
附加项 Additional point	安排有改善社区居民经济和生活条件的项目 In the process of resource management, conservation areas arrange projects to improve the economic and living conditions of community residents	1
附加项 Additional point	争取了国内外减缓和适应气候变化的资金 Nature reserve has secured domestic and international funding for climate change mitigation and adaptation, such as REDD and CCBA	1
28	可持续发展 Sustainable development	3