生物多样性 ›› 2016, Vol. 24 ›› Issue (9): 1009-1013.doi: 10.17520/biods.2016223

所属专题: 物种概念专题

• • 上一篇    下一篇

为什么在物种概念上难以达成共识?

张德兴1, 2, , A;*()   

  1. 1 中国科学院动物研究所, 北京 100101
    2 中国科学院北京基因组研究所, 北京 100101
  • 出版日期:2016-09-20
  • 通讯作者: 张德兴 E-mail:dxzhang@big.ac.cn;dxzhang@ioz.ac.cn
  • 基金项目:
    中国科学院先导专项动物复杂性状的进化解析与调控(XDB13030200)

Why is it so difficult to reach a consensus in species concept?

Dexing Zhang1, 2, *()   

  1. 1 Institute of Zoology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101
    2 Beijing Institute of Genomics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101
  • Online:2016-09-20
  • Contact: Zhang Dexing E-mail:dxzhang@big.ac.cn;dxzhang@ioz.ac.cn

生物学家通常认为物种是生命多样性的基本单位。然而, 尽管近一个世纪以来生物学家们不断地讨论物种概念问题, 但到目前为止仍然难以形成共识。大多数生物学家关注如何定义物种主要是因为它有非常重要的实践意义, 所以, 不同学者提出的物种概念在很大程度上是基于实践应用上的可操作性, 并且其视角难免受其专业见地以及对形成新物种的进化过程的认识所影响。物种代表了进化过程的一个阶段, 而且不同的“物种”可能处于物种形成这个进化过程的不同阶段。鉴于“定义”实际上是一种类似协议的约定或界定, 任何定义都是一种带有局限性的概括, 因此我们可能很难建立一个与分类实践中千变万化的情况都能完全匹配协调的物种定义。已经提出来的那些物种概念或定义都有其合理性, 但是也没有一个是完美无缺的。认识到这一点很重要, 否则就可能会因为固执地坚持某一特定的物种概念而在物种界定和进化研究中自觉或不自觉地引入错误甚至制造混乱。

关键词: 物种, 物种概念, 物种形成, 生殖隔离, 种群分化, 分歧原理, 神奇性状

Biologists believe that species is the basic unit of biological diversity, and few people will doubt the fact that there exist distinct species in nature. Nevertheless, despite of ceaseless debating on species concept or species definition among biologists over nearly a century, no consensus has been reached. Species definition concerns many biologists because it has far-reaching practical implications. Therefore, species concepts proposed by various scholars zero in greatly on their operational convenience and practical applicability in research activity such as taxonomic classification. As a result, these concepts and definitions are unavoidably shaped by the visions of the scholars which are further shaped by their insights into the evolutionary process of speciation. Speciation represents a stage in evolutionary divergence, and also different “species” may be at different stages of the speciation process. Since a “definition” is a kind of convention or confining description, every definition would bear some limitations. It would be thus very difficult, if not impossible, to define a perfect species concept that will accord with all species in taxonomic practice. From this perspective, we should confess that while every species concept or definition proposed thus far is reasonable, none is faultless or flawless. It is very important to bear this in mind, because, otherwise, one may stubbornly insist on one single species concept and introduces errors or even triggers chaos and confusion, consciously or unconsciously, in taxonomic and other evolutionary researches.

Key words: species, species concept, speciation, reproductive isolation, population subdivision, principle of divergence, magic trait

[1] Coyne JA, Orr HA (2004) Speciation. Sinauer, Sunderland, MA.
[2] Darwin C (1859) On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life. John Murray, London.
[3] de Queiroz K (2007) Species concepts and species delimitation. Systematic Biology, 56, 879-886.
[4] Devitt M (2010) Species have (partly) intrinsic essences. Philosophy of Science, 77, 648-661.
[5] Dobzhansky T (1935) A critique of the species concept in biology. Philosophy of Science, 2, 344-355.
[6] Dobzhansky T (1937) Genetics and the Origin of Species. Columbia University Press, New York.
[7] Emerson AE (1938) The origin of species. Ecology, 19, 152-154.
[8] Hong DY (2016) Biodiversity pursuits need a scientific and operative species concept. Biodiversity Science, 24, 979-999. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[洪德元 (2016) 生物多样性事业需要科学、可操作的物种概念. 生物多样性, 24, 979-999.]
[9] Ma L, Ji YJ, Zhang DX (2015) Statistical measures of genetic differentiation of populations: rationales, history and current states. Current Zoology, 61, 886-897.
[10] Mallet J (2010) Why was Darwin’s view of species rejected by mid-20th Century biologists, and how does it fare today? Biology & Philosophy, 25, 497-527.
[11] Mayr E (1940) Speciation phenomena in birds. The American Naturalist, 74, 249-278.
[12] Mayr E (1942) Systematics and the Origin of Species. Columbia University Press, New York.
[13] Orr HA, Irving S (2001) Complex epistasis and the genetic basis of hybrid sterility in the Drosophila pseudoobscura Bogota-USA hybridization. Genetics, 158, 1089-1100.
[14] Ramsey J, Bradshaw HD, Schemske DW (2003) Components of reproductive isolation between the monkeyflowers Mimulus lewisii and M. cardinalis (Phrymaceae). Evolution, 57, 1520-1534.
[15] Servedio MR, van Doorn GS, Kopp M, Frame AM, Nosil P (2011) Magic traits in speciation: ‘magic’ but not rare? Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 26, 389-397.
[16] Via S (2001) Sympatric speciation in animals: the ugly duckling grows up. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 16, 381-390.
[17] Waples RS, Gaggiotti O (2006) What is a population? An empirical evaluation of some genetic methods for identifying the number of gene pools and their degree of connectivity. Molecular Ecology, 15, 1419-1439.
[18] Yang ZH (2014) Molecular Evolution: A Statistical Approach. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
[19] Zhang DX (2010) A neglected dimension of evolution and the origin of species. In: Darwin’s Heritage Today: Proceedings of the Darwin 200 Beijing International Conference (eds Long M, Gu H, Zhou Z), pp. 271-287. Higher Education Press, Beijing.
[1] 李帅锋 郎学东 黄小波 王艳红 刘万德 徐崇华 苏建荣. (2020) 云南普洱30hm2季风常绿阔叶林动态监测样地群丛数量分类. 植物生态学报, 44(预发表): 0-0.
[2] 蒋志刚 江建平 王跃招 张鹗 张雁云 蔡波. (2020) 国家濒危物种红色名录的生物多样性保护意义. 生物多样性, 28(5): 0-0.
[3] 朱俊华 吴宙 冯炳斌 邓帅帅 甄文全 廖永岩 颉晓勇 Kit Yue Kwan. (2020) 全球中华鲎资源保护现状及对策建议. 生物多样性, 28(5): 0-0.
[4] 李娜 丁晨晨 曹丹丹 初红军 戚英杰 李春旺 平晓鸽 孙悦华 蒋志刚. (2020) 中国阿勒泰地区鸟类物种编目、丰富度格局和区系组成. 生物多样性, 28(4): 401-411.
[5] 刘丹,郭忠玲,崔晓阳,范春楠. (2020) 5种东北红豆杉植物群丛及其物种多样性的比较. 生物多样性, 28(3): 340-349.
[6] 刘振元,孟星亮,李正飞,张君倩,徐靖,银森录,谢志才. (2020) 南洞庭湖区软体动物物种多样性评估及保护对策. 生物多样性, 28(2): 155-165.
[7] 刘旻霞,李全弟,蒋晓轩,夏素娟,南笑宁,张娅娅,李博文. (2020) 甘南亚高寒草甸稀有种对物种多样性和物种多度分布格局的贡献. 生物多样性, 28(2): 107-116.
[8] 王剀,任金龙,陈宏满,吕植桐,郭宪光,蒋珂,陈进民,李家堂,郭鹏,王英永,车静. (2020) 中国两栖、爬行动物更新名录. 生物多样性, 28(2): 189-218.
[9] 李霞,朱万泽,孙守琴,舒树淼,盛哲良,张军,刘亭,张志才. (2020) 大渡河中游干暖河谷区生境对植物群落分布格局和多样性的影响. 生物多样性, 28(2): 117-127.
[10] 丁威,王玉冰,向官海,迟永刚,鲁顺保,郑淑霞. (2020) 小叶锦鸡儿灌丛化对典型草原群落结构与生态系统功能的影响. 植物生态学报, 44(1): 33-43.
[11] 李熠,唐志尧,闫昱晶,王科,蔡磊,贺金生,古松,姚一建. (2020) 物种分布模型在大型真菌红色名录评估及保护中的应用: 以冬虫夏草为例. 生物多样性, 28(1): 99-106.
[12] 魏铁铮,王科,于晓丹,李熠,吴海军,吴红梅,王永会,卫晓丹,李斌斌,蒋岚,姚一建. (2020) 中国大型担子菌受威胁现状评估. 生物多样性, 28(1): 41-53.
[13] 王玉冰,孙毅寒,丁威,张恩涛,李文怀,迟永刚,郑淑霞. (2020) 长期氮添加对典型草原植物多样性与初级生产力的影响及途径. 植物生态学报, 44(1): 22-32.
[14] 唐丽丽,杨彤,刘鸿雁,康慕谊,王仁卿,张峰,高贤明,岳明,张梅,郑璞帆,石福臣. (2019) 华北地区荆条灌丛分布及物种多样性空间分异 规律. 植物生态学报, 43(9): 825-833.
[15] 谭一波,申文辉,付孜,郑威,欧芷阳,谭长强,彭玉华,庞世龙,何琴飞,黄小荣,何峰. (2019) 环境因子对桂西南蚬木林下植被物种多样性变异的解释. 生物多样性, 27(9): 970-983.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited

  Shared   
  Discussed