Effects of ecological engineering on net primary production in the Chang Tang and Sanjiangyuan national nature reserves on the Tibetan Plateau

doi:10.17520/biods.2015082

Abstract

Abstract:

Long term series of remotely sensed imagery of net primary production (NPP) data could reflect ecosystem health. In this study, we employed NPP to evaluate the effects of ecological engineering (nature reserve and new ecological engineering in 2004 or 2005 techniques) by the sampling area comparison method in the Chang Tang and Sanjiangyuan national nature reserves on the Tibetan Plateau. The results showed that: (1) among the 10 pairs of sampling areas, annual NPP of 9 pairs tended to increase between 1982 and 2009; (2) the new ecological engineering techniques improved the effectiveness of ecosystem conservation, with NPP in 8 pairs of sampling areas increasing faster than before; and (3) among all alpine grassland types, the new ecological engineering techniques remarkably improved the effectiveness of conserving the meadows.

http://jtp.cnki.net/bilingual/detail/html/SWDY201602002

Key words: ecological engineering, nature reserve, net primary production, Sanjiangyuan, Chang Tang, sampling area comparison method

Wei Qi, Wanqi Bai, Yili Zhang, Xue Wu, Lanhui Li, Mingjun Ding, Caiping Zhou. Effects of ecological engineering on net primary production in the Chang Tang and Sanjiangyuan national nature reserves on the Tibetan Plateau[J]. Biodiv Sci, 2016, 24(2): 127-135.

Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

URL: https://www.biodiversity-science.net/EN/10.17520/biods.2015082

https://www.biodiversity-science.net/EN/Y2016/V24/I2/127

Figures/Tables 5

References 31

1	Chang HQ, Xu WY, Yuan J, Lü JZ, Zhang SX (2012) Current situation of grassland resources and grazing capacity in Ali, Tibet. Pratacultural Science, 29, 1660-1664. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[畅慧勤, 徐文勇, 袁杰, 吕继照, 张硕新 (2012) 西藏阿里草地资源现状及载畜量. 草业科学, 29, 1660-1664.]
2	Chen BX, Zhang XZ, Tao J, Wu JS, Wang JS, Shi PL, Zhang YJ, Yu CQ (2014) The impact of climate change and anthropogenic activities on alpine grassland over the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 189, 11-18.
3	Crabtree R, Potter C, Mullen R, Sheldon J, Huang S, Harmsen J, Rodman A, Jean C (2009) A modeling and spatio- temporal analysis framework for monitoring environmental change using NPP as an ecosystem indicator. Remote Sensing of Environment, 113, 1486-1496.
4	Gao QZ, Wan YF, Li YE, Lin ED, Yang K, Jiangcun WZ, Wang BS, Li WF (2007) Grassland net primary productivity and its spatio-temporal distribution in northern Tibet: a study with CASA model. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 18, 2526-2532. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[高清竹, 万运帆, 李玉娥, 林而达, 杨凯, 江村旺扎, 王宝山, 李文福 (2007) 基于CASA模型的藏北地区草地植被净第一性生产力及其时空格局. 应用生态学报, 18, 2526-2532.]
5	Lai M, Wu SH, Dai EF, Yin YH, Pan T, Zhao DS (2013) Dynamic valuation on ecosystem services to ecological construction in the Three-River Headwaters Nature Reserve, China. Journal of Mountain Science, 31, 8-17. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[赖敏, 吴绍洪, 戴尔阜, 尹云鹤, 潘韬, 赵东升 (2013) 生态建设背景下三江源自然保护区生态系统服务价值变化. 山地学报, 31, 8-17.]
6	Li SD (1993) The ecological projects in the world. World Environment, 11, 31-35. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[李世东 (1993) 世界生态工程建设综述. 世界环境, 11, 31-35.]
7	Li SD (2001) The construction progress and implications of major forest ecological projects in the world. Forestry Economics, 23(12), 46-50. (in Chinese)
	[李世东 (2001) 世界重点林业生态工程建设进展及其启示. 林业经济, 23(12), 46-50.]
8	Liu JG, Li SX, Ouyang ZY, Tam C, Chen XD (2008a) Ecological and socioeconomic effects of China’s policies for ecosystem services. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 105, 9477-9482.
9	Liu JY, Shao QQ, Fan JW (2013) Ecological construction achievements assessment and its revelation of ecological project in Three Rivers Headwaters Region. Chinese Journal of Nature, 35(1), 40-46. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[刘纪远, 邵全琴, 樊江文 (2013) 三江源生态工程的生态成效评估与启示. 自然杂志, 35(1), 40-46.]
10	Liu JY, Xu XL, Shao QQ (2008b) Grassland degradation in the “Three-River Headwaters” region, Qinghai Province. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 18, 259-273.
11	Liu XF, Ren ZY, Lin ZH, Liu YX, Zhang DH (2013) The spatial-temporal changes of vegetation coverage in the Three-River Headwater Region in recent 12 years. Acta Geographica Sinica, 68, 897-908. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[刘宪锋, 任志远, 林志慧, 刘焱序, 张东海 (2013) 2000-2011年三江源区植被覆盖时空变化特征. 地理学报, 68, 897-908.]
12	Luo TY, Long SB, Ren R, He Z (2010) Problems and countermeasures of the wind erosion with desertification control project in Beijing. Soil and Water Conservation in China, 31(7), 30-32. (in Chinese)
	[罗添元, 龙少波, 任认, 何政 (2010) 北京市风沙治理生态工程存在的问题与对策. 中国水土保持, 31(7), 30-32.]
13	Qian S, Fu Y, Pan FF (2010) Climate change tendency and grassland vegetation response during the growth season in Three-River Source Region. Science China: Earth Sciences, 53, 1506-1512.
14	Qin HR (2012) Stronge implement grazing grass and fully implement the strategy for establishing province by ecological. Qinghai Prataculture, 21(1), 34-36. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[秦海蓉 (2012) 认真实施退牧还草, 全面落实生态立省战略. 青海草业, 21(1), 34-36.]
15	Shao QQ, Fan JW (2012) Integrated Monitoring and Assess- ment of Ecosystem in the Three River Source Region. Science Press, Beijing. (in Chinese)
	[邵全琴, 樊江文 (2012) 三江源区生态系统综合监测与评估. 科学出版社, 北京]
16	Shao QQ, Liu JY, Huang L, Fan JW, Xu XL, Wang JB (2013) Integrated assessment on the effectiveness of ecological conservation in Sanjiangyuan National Nature Reserve. Geographical Research, 32, 1645-1656. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[邵全琴, 刘纪远, 黄麟, 樊江文, 徐新良, 王军邦 (2013) 2005-2009年三江源自然保护区生态保护和建设工程生态成效综合评估. 地理研究, 32, 1645-1656.]
17	Shvidenko AZ, Schepashchenko DG, Vaganov EA, Nilsson S (2008) Net primary production of forest ecosystems of Russia: a new estimate. Doklady Earth Science, 421, 1009-1012.
18	Sun HL, Zheng D, Yao TD, Zhang YL (2012) Protection and construction of the national ecological security shelter zone on Tibetan Plateau. Acta Geographica Sinica, 67, 3-12. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[孙鸿烈, 郑度, 姚檀栋, 张镱锂 (2012) 青藏高原国家生态安全屏障保护与建设. 地理学报, 67, 3-12.]
19	Wang JS, Zhang XZ, Zhao YP, Qin SG, Wu JS (2010) Spatio-temporal pattern of alpine grassland productivity in Qiangtang Plateau. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 21, 1400-1404. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[王景升, 张宪洲, 赵玉萍, 秦泗国, 武建双) (2010) 羌塘高原高寒草地生态系统生产力动态. 应用生态学报, 21, 1400-1404.]
20	Wang JS, Zhang XZ, Zhao YP, Shen ZX, Shi PL, Yu CQ (2008) Spatio-temporal pattern of climate changes in northern Tibet’s Qiangtang Plateau. Resources Science, 30, 1852-1859. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[王景升, 张宪洲, 赵玉萍, 沈振西, 石培礼, 余成群 (2008) 藏北羌塘高原气候变化的时空格局. 资源科学, 30, 1852-1859.]
21	Xiao T, Liu JY, Shao QQ (2009) A simulation on changes in vegetation productivity in “Three River Sources” Nature Reserve, Qinghai Province over past 20 years. Journal of Geo-information Science, 11, 557-565. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[肖桐, 刘纪远, 邵全琴 (2009) 近20年青海三江源自然保护区植被生产力变化模拟. 地球信息科学学报, 11, 557-565.]
22	Yan JS, Wang RS (2001) Advances of ecological engineering in China in the past decade. Rural Eco-Environment, 17(1), 1-8, 20. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[颜京松, 王如松 (2001) 近十年生态工程在中国的进展. 农村生态环境, 17(1), 1-8, 20.]
23	Zhang HZ, Lu HY, Hong JC, Ma PF (2013) Climate change and its effect on steppe animal husbandry in northwest Tibet. Arid Zone Research, 30, 308-314. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[张核真, 路红亚, 洪健昌, 马鹏飞 (2013) 藏西北地区气候变化及其对草地畜牧业的影响. 干旱区研究, 30, 308-314.]
24	Zhang L (2012) One of excellent ecological engineering models of Florida, USA—Freedom Park. Wetland Science & Management, 8(4), 56-57. (in Chinese)
	[张立 (2012) 美国佛罗里达生态工程典范之一——佛州西南的湿地公园. 湿地科学与管理, 8(4), 56-57.]
25	Zhang RZ, Li BY, Zhang HX, Liu LS (2012) Regional System of Nature Reserves in China. China Environmental Science Press, Beijing. (in Chinese)
	[张荣祖, 李炳元, 张豪禧, 刘林山) (2012)中国自然保护区区划系统研究. 中国环境科学出版社, 北京.]
26	Zhang W (2007) Research of Land Use/Cover Classification and Carbon Stocks—A Case Study on Tibetan Plateau . PhD dissertation, Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing.(in Chinese with English abstract)
	[张玮 (2007) 土地利用/覆被分类与碳储量研究——以青藏高原为例. 博士学位论文, 中国科学院地理科学与资源研究所, 北京.]
27	Zhang YL, Li BY, Zheng D (2002) A discussion on the boundary and area of the Tibetan Plateau in China. Geographical Research, 21, 1-8. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[张镱锂, 李炳元, 郑度 (2002) 论青藏高原范围与面积. 地理研究, 21, 1-8.]
28	Zhang YL, Hu ZJ, Qi W, Wu X, Bai WQ, Li LH, Ding MJ, Liu LS, Wang ZF, Zheng D (2015a) Assessment of protection effectiveness of nature reserves on the Tibetan Plateau based on net primary production and the large-sample-comparison method. Acta Geographica Sinica, 70, 1027-1040. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[张镱锂, 胡忠俊, 祁威, 吴雪, 摆万奇, 李兰晖, 丁明军, 刘林山, 王兆锋, 郑度 (2015a) 基于NPP数据和样区对比法的青藏高原自然保护区保护成效分析. 地理学报, 70, 1027-1040.]
29	Zhang YL, Qi W, Zhou CP, Ding MJ, Liu LS, Gao JG, Bai WQ, Wang ZF, Zheng D (2013) Spatial and temporal variability in the net primary production (NPP) of alpine grassland on Tibetan Plateau from 1982 to 2009. Acta Geographica Sinica, 68, 1197-1211. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[张镱锂, 祁威, 周才平, 丁明军, 刘林山, 高俊刚, 摆万奇, 王兆锋, 郑度 (2013) 青藏高原高寒草地净初级生产力(NPP)时空分异. 地理学报, 68, 1197-1211.]
30	Zhang YL, Wu X, Qi W, Li SC, Bai WQ (2015b) Character- istics and protection effects of the nature reserves in Tibetan Plateau, China. Resources Science, 37, 1455-1464. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[张镱锂, 吴雪, 祁威, 李士成, 摆万奇 (2015b) 青藏高原自然保护区特征与保护成效简析. 资源科学, 37, 1455-1464.]
31	Zheng YM, Zhang HY, Niu ZG, Gong P (2012) Protection efficacy of national wetland reserves in China. Chinese Science Bulletin, 57, 1116-1134.

样区编号 No. of sampling area	自然保护区 Nature reserve	高寒草地类型 Type of alpine grassland	样区内/外有效像元数(个) Number of effective pixels of sampling areas (inside/outside)	样区编号 No. of sampling area	自然保护区 Nature reserve	高寒草地类型 Type of alpine grassland	样区内/外有效像元数(个) Number of effective pixels of l sampling areas (inside/outside)
01	羌塘 Chang Tang	高寒荒漠 Alpine desert	62/66	06	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	115/106
02	羌塘 Chang Tang	高寒草原 Alpine steppe	102/84	07	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	115/145
03	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	70/95	08	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	125/94
04	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	132/98	09	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	77/80
05	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	148/95	10	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草原 Alpine steppe	70/70

样区编号 No. of sampling area	自然保护区 Nature reserve	高寒草地类型 Type of alpine grassland	样区内/外有效像元数(个) Number of effective pixels of sampling areas (inside/outside)	样区编号 No. of sampling area	自然保护区 Nature reserve	高寒草地类型 Type of alpine grassland	样区内/外有效像元数(个) Number of effective pixels of l sampling areas (inside/outside)
01	羌塘 Chang Tang	高寒荒漠 Alpine desert	62/66	06	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	115/106
02	羌塘 Chang Tang	高寒草原 Alpine steppe	102/84	07	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	115/145
03	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	70/95	08	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	125/94
04	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	132/98	09	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	77/80
05	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草甸 Alpine meadow	148/95	10	三江源 Sanjiangyuan	高寒草原 Alpine steppe	70/70

样区 Sampling area		分析时段 Analysis period				第二阶段与第一阶段的NPP变化速率差值(P_2-1)^* The difference of NPP change rate between the second stage and the first stage (P_2-1)^*	第三阶段与第一阶段的NPP变化速率差值(P_3-1)^* The difference of NPP change rate between the third stage and the first stage (P_3-1)^*
编号 No.	样区组 Sampling area pair	全时段^* (1982-2009) Whole period (1982-2009)	第一阶段(K₁)^(1982年至建立自然保护区) First stage (K₁)^(1982 to implementation of nature reserve)	第二阶段(K₂)(建立自然保护区至实施新生态工程) Second stage (K₂) (implementation of nature reserve to new ecological engineering in 2000s)	第三阶段(K₃) (实施新生态工程至2009年) Third stage (K₃) (implementation of new ecological engineering in 2000s to 2009)
01	区内 Inside	0.057	-0.005	-0.222	3.067	-0.163	0.288
01	区外 Outside	-0.004	-0.194	-0.248	2.591	-0.163	0.288
02	区内 Inside	0.108	0.134	0.073	2.454	0.108	-0.640
02	区外 Outside	0.104	0.072	-0.097	3.032	0.108	-0.640
03	区内 Inside	0.095	0.170	-3.709	6.896	-1.529	1.700
03	区外 Outside	0.085	0.096	-2.253	5.122	-1.529	1.700
04	区内 Inside	-0.131	-0.382	-3.768	4.561	-0.872	0.170
04	区外 Outside	0.130	-0.012	-2.527	4.761	-0.872	0.170
05	区内 Inside	0.524	-0.287	-2.619	15.643	-1.303	9.778
05	区外 Outside	0.537	0.320	-0.709	6.472	-1.303	9.778
06	区内 Inside	0.643	0.094	-0.750	2.200	1.119	1.717
06	区外 Outside	0.654	0.479	-1.485	0.868	1.119	1.717
07	区内 Inside	0.721	-0.134	4.287	-2.174	0.934	1.951
07	区外 Outside	0.742	-0.167	3.321	-4.158	0.934	1.951
08	区内 Inside	1.291	1.588	3.770	-9.409	5.422	0.587
08	区外 Outside	1.370	2.075	-1.165	-9.509	5.422	0.587
09	区内 Inside	0.813	0.533	-0.138	-5.442	-0.346	1.390
09	区外 Outside	0.621	0.716	0.390	-6.649	-0.346	1.390
10	区内 Inside	1.104	-0.943	4.482	20.468	-7.384	8.197
10	区外 Outside	1.157	-1.050	11.759	12.165	-7.384	8.197

样区 Sampling area		分析时段 Analysis period				第二阶段与第一阶段的NPP变化速率差值(P_2-1)^* The difference of NPP change rate between the second stage and the first stage (P_2-1)^*	第三阶段与第一阶段的NPP变化速率差值(P_3-1)^* The difference of NPP change rate between the third stage and the first stage (P_3-1)^*
编号 No.	样区组 Sampling area pair	全时段^* (1982-2009) Whole period (1982-2009)	第一阶段(K₁)^(1982年至建立自然保护区) First stage (K₁)^(1982 to implementation of nature reserve)	第二阶段(K₂)(建立自然保护区至实施新生态工程) Second stage (K₂) (implementation of nature reserve to new ecological engineering in 2000s)	第三阶段(K₃) (实施新生态工程至2009年) Third stage (K₃) (implementation of new ecological engineering in 2000s to 2009)
01	区内 Inside	0.057	-0.005	-0.222	3.067	-0.163	0.288
01	区外 Outside	-0.004	-0.194	-0.248	2.591	-0.163	0.288
02	区内 Inside	0.108	0.134	0.073	2.454	0.108	-0.640
02	区外 Outside	0.104	0.072	-0.097	3.032	0.108	-0.640
03	区内 Inside	0.095	0.170	-3.709	6.896	-1.529	1.700
03	区外 Outside	0.085	0.096	-2.253	5.122	-1.529	1.700
04	区内 Inside	-0.131	-0.382	-3.768	4.561	-0.872	0.170
04	区外 Outside	0.130	-0.012	-2.527	4.761	-0.872	0.170
05	区内 Inside	0.524	-0.287	-2.619	15.643	-1.303	9.778
05	区外 Outside	0.537	0.320	-0.709	6.472	-1.303	9.778
06	区内 Inside	0.643	0.094	-0.750	2.200	1.119	1.717
06	区外 Outside	0.654	0.479	-1.485	0.868	1.119	1.717
07	区内 Inside	0.721	-0.134	4.287	-2.174	0.934	1.951
07	区外 Outside	0.742	-0.167	3.321	-4.158	0.934	1.951
08	区内 Inside	1.291	1.588	3.770	-9.409	5.422	0.587
08	区外 Outside	1.370	2.075	-1.165	-9.509	5.422	0.587
09	区内 Inside	0.813	0.533	-0.138	-5.442	-0.346	1.390
09	区外 Outside	0.621	0.716	0.390	-6.649	-0.346	1.390
10	区内 Inside	1.104	-0.943	4.482	20.468	-7.384	8.197
10	区外 Outside	1.157	-1.050	11.759	12.165	-7.384	8.197

[1]	Xuemeng Li, Jibao Jiang, Zenglu Zhang, Xiaojing Liu, Yali Wang, Yizhao Wu, Yinsheng Li, Jiangping Qiu, Qi Zhao. Earthworm biodiversity and its influencing factors in Baotianman National Nature Reserve [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2024, 32(4): 23352-.
[2]	Qifan Wang, Xiaohui Liu, Ziwei Zhu, Lei Liu, Xinxue Wang, Xuyang Ji, Shaochun Zhou, Zidong Zhang, Hongyu Dong, Minghai Zhang. Mammal and avian diversity in Beijicun National Nature Reserve, Heilongjiang Province, China [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2024, 32(4): 24024-.
[3]	Suo Di, Yu Ruoxi, Li Yuanhui, Xu Jiliang. Problem review and optimization path of local legislation in nature reserves in China based on empirical analysis [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2024, 32(2): 23287-.
[4]	Liu Xiaolin, Wu Yougui, Zhang Minhua, Chen Xiaorong, Zhu Zhicheng, Chen Dingyun, Dong Shu, Li Buhang, Ding Bingyang, Liu Yu. Community composition and structure of a 25-ha forest dynamics plot of subtropical forest in Baishanzu, Zhejiang Province [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2024, 32(2): 23294-.
[5]	Huang Xiaolong, Meng Bingshun, Li Haibo, Ran Wei, Yang Wei, Wang Cheng, Xie Bo, Zhang Xu, Ran Jingcheng, Zhang Mingming. Interspecific associations between Rhinopithecus brelichi and its sympatric species using infrared cameras [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2024, 32(2): 23402-.
[6]	Guofa Cui. Discussion and suggestions on several key issues in the integration and optimization of protected areas [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2023, 31(9): 22447-.
[7]	Chao Xing, Yi Lin, Zhiqiang Zhou, Lianjun Zhao, Shiwei Jiang, Zhenzhen Lin, Jiliang Xu, Xiangjiang Zhan. The establishment of terrestrial vertebrate genetic resource bank and species identification based on DNA barcoding in Wanglang National Nature Reserve [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2023, 31(7): 22661-.
[8]	Benping Chen, Jianwu Chen, Zhengwen Ling, Xu Yang, Xin Chen, Shengqiang Li, Biao Yang. Developing a dataset on the diversity and dynamic changes of mammals and birds recorded using camera traps in Laojun Mountain National Nature Reserve, Sichuan, China [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2023, 31(5): 22566-.
[9]	Xue Yao, Xing Chen, Zun Dai, Kun Song, Shichen Xing, Hongyu Cao, Lu Zou, Jian Wang. Importance of collection strategy on detection probability and species diversity of epiphyllous liverworts [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2023, 31(4): 22685-.
[10]	Mengqiao Zhao, You Chen, Zhenghui Xu, Xubo Wang, Zhongliang Zhao, Wenchuan Xu, Zonghui He, Wenhua Wang. Ant species diversity along the vertical zones of the east slope of Ailao Mountain National Nature Reserve, Yunnan Province [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2023, 31(11): 23168-.
[11]	Yuanfang Hu, Binqiang Li, Dan Liang, Xingquan Li, Lanxiang Liu, Jiawei Yang, Xu Luo. Effect of anthropogenic disturbance on Lady Amherst’s pheasant (Chrysolophus amherstiae) activity [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2022, 30(8): 21484-.
[12]	Wenna Tu, Jiawei Yi, Yunyan Du, Nan Wang, Jiale Qian, Sheng Huang, Xiaoyue Wang. A spatiotemporal analysis of human digital footprint and the human activities exposure of grassland biomass in Qinghai Lake National Nature Reserve [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2022, 30(6): 21310-.
[13]	Haiping Li, Zhuqing Xu, Zhihang Long. Conservation gap analysis of key protected and rare animals in Da Hinggan Range Region, China [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2022, 30(2): 21294-.
[14]	Le Qin, Yanpeng Zhu, Yueheng Ren, Boyan Li, Mengdi Fu, Junsheng Li. Differences in management capacity of national nature reserves on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau and the impact on conservation effectiveness [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2022, 30(11): 22419-.
[15]	Wei Wang, Yue Zhou, Yu Tian, Junsheng Li. Biodiversity conservation research in protected areas: A review [J]. Biodiv Sci, 2022, 30(10): 22459-.